• Home
  • Firm Overview
  • Attorney Profiles
    • Jerry L. McIntyre
    • Deborah Miller Tate
    • Robert S. Parker
    • Robert Joseph Sgroi
    • Stephen M. Prignano
    • Laura Ruzzo Reale
    • Nicholas Hunt
  • Family Law
    • Adoption
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Visitation
    • Common Law Marriage
    • Divorce
      • Uncontested Divorce
      • High Net Worth Divorce
      • Celebrity & High-Profile Divorce
    • Domestic Violence
    • Grandparent’s Visitation Rights
    • Parental Relocation
    • Modifications
    • Post-Divorce Issues
      • Enforcement of Orders
    • Premarital & Cohabitation Agreements
    • Property Settlement
    • Same Sex Relationship Issues/Divorce
    • Uncovering Hidden Assets
    • Unmarried Couples
  • Civil Law
    • Business and Commercial Litigation
    • Class Actions
    • Construction Defect Litigation
    • Contract Disputes
    • Disability Insurance Litigation
    • Insurance Litigation
    • Media Liability
    • Personal Injury
    • Product Liability
    • Professional Malpractice Litigation
  • Firm News
  • Blog
    • 2022
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
    • 2021
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
    • 2020
      • October
      • September
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • January
    • 2019
      • December
      • November
      • May
      • February
    • 2018
      • September
      • June
      • February
      • January
    • 2017
      • December
      • November
      • September
      • August
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • February
      • January
    • 2016
      • December
      • November
      • October
      • September
      • August
      • June
      • May
      • April
      • March
      • January
    • 2015
      • December
      • November
      • September
      • August
      • July
      • June
      • May
      • April
    • 2014
      • December
      • November
      • June
      • May
      • January
    • 2013
      • December
      • November
      • July
      • June
      • April
      • March
      • February
    • 2012
      • August
  • Contact Us
  • Call Today
  • Email Us
  • Our Map
    • McIntyre Tate LLP
    • 401.351.7700
    • Home
    • Firm Overview
    • Attorney Profiles
      • Jerry L. McIntyre
      • Deborah Miller Tate
      • Robert S. Parker
      • Robert Joseph Sgroi
      • Stephen M. Prignano
      • Laura Ruzzo Reale
      • Nicholas Hunt
    • Family Law
      • Adoption
      • Child Custody
      • Child Support
      • Visitation
      • Common Law Marriage
      • Divorce
        • Uncontested Divorce
        • High Net Worth Divorce
        • Celebrity & High-Profile Divorce
      • Domestic Violence
      • Grandparent’s Visitation Rights
      • Parental Relocation
      • Modifications
      • Post-Divorce Issues
        • Enforcement of Orders
      • Premarital & Cohabitation Agreements
      • Property Settlement
      • Same Sex Relationship Issues/Divorce
      • Uncovering Hidden Assets
      • Unmarried Couples
    • Civil Law
      • Business and Commercial Litigation
      • Class Actions
      • Construction Defect Litigation
      • Contract Disputes
      • Disability Insurance Litigation
      • Insurance Litigation
      • Media Liability
      • Personal Injury
      • Product Liability
      • Professional Malpractice Litigation
    • Firm News
    • Blog
      • 2022
        • May
        • April
        • March
          • Attorney Deborah Tate Featured in Bradley Hospital Bulletin
        • February
          • Nicholas Hunt Joins Legal Team at McIntyre Tate LLP
        • January
      • 2021
        • December
        • November
          • Attorney Deborah Tate Quoted About COVID-19 Disputes in Divorce
        • October
          • How Adoption Works in Rhode Island
          • What Are the Requirements to Adopt a Child in Rhode Island?
        • September
          • Is Your Spouse Hiding Money? Create a Fair Divorce Settlement
          • Can a Judge Invalidate a Prenuptial Agreement?
          • Attorney Stephen M. Prignano Recognized by Best Lawyers®
        • August
          • How Do the Courts Handle Animal Cruelty and Neglect Cases?
          • Laura Ruzzo Reale Recognized by Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in 2022
        • July
          • U.S. Divorce Rate Hits 50-Year Low
        • June
          • How to Uncover Hidden Assets in a Divorce
        • May
          • Factors Impacting Spousal Support in Rhode Island
        • April
          • The Importance of Establishing a Prenup in a High Net Worth Divorce
          • Attorney Deborah Tate Quoted in The Providence Journal Article on COVID-19 & Divorce
        • March
          • How to Avoid Getting Sued as a Member of the Media
          • Laura Ruzzo Reale Elected to Partner of McIntyre Tate LLP
        • February
          • How Long Do You Have to Pay Spousal Support?
        • January
          • Understanding Parenthood for Same-Sex Couples
      • 2020
        • October
          • Stephen M. Prignano of McIntyre Tate LLP Recognized in 27th Edition of The Best Lawyers in America©
        • September
          • Laura Ruzzo Reale: Best® Lawyers® in America “Ones to Watch” Award
        • July
          • Can I Reduce My Spousal Support Payments?
        • June
          • How COVID-19 Turned Business Insurance into a Legal Battleground
          • Stephen Prignano Quoted in Rhode Island Lawyer’s Weekly Regarding the Impact of COVID-19 on Business Interruption Insurance Clai
        • May
          • Will Infidelity Affect My Divorce Settlement?
          • Brown University Student Represented by Hagens Berman and McIntyre Tate Files Class Action Lawsuit Over COVID-19
          • COVID-19 Helpline Featured in Providence Journal
        • April
          • How COVID-19 Affects Guardians
          • American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers Issues Guidelines for Divorced Parents Sharing Custody of their Children During the Covi
          • McIntyre Tate LLP Launches Free COVID-19 Helpline
        • March
          • Rhode Island Superior Court Announces COVID-19 Business Recovery Plan
        • January
          • Methods of Dividing Damages in Divorce
          • Contempt for Unpaid Child Support
      • 2019
        • December
          • Are Millennials Really Divorcing Less Often Than Past Generations?
          • Think About This When Divorcing as an Entrepreneur
          • Celebrating 25 Years of McIntyre Tate LLP
          • Overview of Supervised Parenting Time in Rhode Island
          • Property Division in Rhode Island - Transmutation
          • McIntyre Tate team of Attorneys Deborah Tate and Robert Parker Win in Parental Relocation Case
        • November
          • Questions to Ask Your Divorce Attorney Right Away
          • Attorney Prignano Selected to Best Lawyers in America® 2020
          • Visitation Schedules in Rhode Island: Residential, Holiday & Vacation
          • McIntyre Tate Ranked in 2 Practice Areas by U.S. News – Best Lawyers® “Best Law Firms”
        • May
          • Attorney Stephen M. Prignano of McIntyre Tate LLP Presented with 2019 Community Champion Award
          • Pet Custody & Visitation: Important Decisions in Your Divorce
        • February
          • Attorney Deborah M. Tate has been chosen as an honoree at the Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly “Excellence in the Law” event
      • 2018
        • September
          • Attorney Prignano of McIntyre Tate Has Been Selected as a 2019 Best Lawyers® Member
          • Upcoming Divorce & Estate Planning Seminar to Feature Attorney Stephen Prignano
        • June
          • Common Law Marriage: Luis vs. Gaugler
        • February
          • Solving Contract Disputes That Bother Your Business
        • January
          • What You Need to Know About the New Alimony Tax Laws
          • Pet Leases: A New Trend
      • 2017
        • December
          • Relocation Cases in Divorce: Who Stays with the Children?
        • November
          • Client Buys Dog in China with Now-Ex-Boyfriend, Ownership Issue Arises
          • Attorney Stephen M. Prignano Selected to 24th Edition of The Best Lawyers in America® for Commercial Litigation
          • Rhode Island Child Custody Laws for Unmarried Parents
          • Attorney Deborah M. Tate Elected to Bradley Hospital Foundation Board of Governors
        • September
          • Do You Need a Divorce Lawyer?
        • August
          • Best Lawyers in America© Recognizes Attorney Deborah Tate for Family Law
        • June
          • How Can Wasteful Dissipation Impact Your Divorce?
          • Attorney Stephen Prignano Leads Panel at Rhode Island Bar Association Annual Meeting
          • Courts continue to address the definition of "parent" to extend beyond the traditional "normal" gender considerations to now inc
        • May
          • Robert J. Sgroi Lectures at National Business Institute Seminar
          • Attorney Tate Discusses Joint Custody Concerns with Super Lawyers®
          • South Carolina Rules on Same-Sex Common Law Marriage
        • April
          • Rhode Island Supreme Court Rules in Glassie v. Doucette
        • March
          • Former Spouse Cannot Seek Modification of Divorce Agreement in Rhode Island Federal Court
          • Rhode Island Legislator Proposes Family Court Custody Jurisdiction for Pets in Divorce and Separation Proceedings
        • February
          • The Rhode Island Supreme Court Affirms a McIntyre Tate LLP Win in the Rhode Island Family Court
          • Attorney Stephen Prignano to Speak at Lunch and Learn Seminar
        • January
          • Obtaining a Restraining Order in Rhode Island
          • Types of Child Custody in Rhode Island
          • Adoption Tax Credit
          • Rhode Island Supreme Court Upholds Child Support Guidelines
          • Attorney Stephen Prignano to Receive Champions of Justice Award
      • 2016
        • December
          • Six Modern Divorce Trends
          • Attorney Deborah Miller Tate Comments on Federal Domestic Relations Decision
        • November
          • NOVEMBER IS NATIONAL ADOPTION MONTH
          • New Trend In Custody: Nesting, Sharing A Single Home
          • How is a common law marriage established in Rhode Island?
        • October
          • Attorneys Deborah Tate & Stephen Prignano to Give Domestic Law Seminar
          • Three McIntyre Tate Attorneys Named New England Super Lawyers by Thomson Reuters for 2017
          • NY Court Awards Sole Custody to Father after Mother Attempts to "Brainwash" Child
          • Social Media Evidence Becoming Important in Divorce and Custody Cases
          • Partanen v. Gallagher: Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts holds that the absence of a biological relationship with a child
          • Attorney David J. Strachman Quoted in Bloomberg News
        • September
          • Navigating a "Gray Divorce"
          • Life Insurance in Divorce
        • August
          • Three McIntyre Tate LLP Attorneys to Present at National Business Institute Course
          • Stephen Prignano Quoted About Rhode Island Rules of Professional Conduct
          • Two McIntyre Tate LLP Attorneys Honored by Best Lawyers®
        • June
          • Gay Custody Disputes
        • May
          • Stephen Prignano selected to edit Rhode Island chapter of the Media Law Resource Center's book
          • Deborah Tate selected again for The Best Lawyers in America
        • April
          • McIntyre Tate obtains sucessful ruling in Ninth Circuit
        • March
          • Stephen Prignano profiled in Rhode Island Lawyer's Weekly
        • January
          • McIntyre Tate partner David Strachman publishes article on Equitable Adoption
      • 2015
        • December
          • R.I. Supreme Court Rules on Post-Divorce Life Insurance Case
          • Grandparents visitation rights in Rhode Island
          • Robert Sgroi Named 2015 Kent County Lawyer of the Year
        • November
          • New restrictions on surrogacy
          • Rhode Island Supreme Court Adoption Decision
          • Stephen Prignano quoted about drone operations
          • McIntyre Tate LLP client testifies before the U.S. Senate
        • September
          • The Right to Dispose of Decedent's Remains Includes Choosing Content on Headstone
          • Stephen Prignano interviewed in Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly on Uber litigation and class action appeal
          • Stephen Prignano to speak on family law
        • August
          • Laura E. Ruzzo joins McIntyre Tate LLP
          • McIntyre Tate LLP partner Stephen Prignano selected a Best Lawyer
        • July
          • Jerry McIntyre and Deborah Tate selected Best Lawyers
        • June
          • Deborah Tate to speak to Rhode Island CPAs
        • May
          • McIntyre Tate successful in Supreme Court civil rights appeal
          • Elder law information for guardians and substitute decision makers
        • April
          • Changes in Rhode Island DUI laws
          • Deborah M. Tate receives Harvard negotiation certificate
          • McIntyre Tate LLP partner featured in Providence Journal article
          • Stephen Prignano joins McIntyre Tate LLP
          • Decline in international adoptions
      • 2014
        • December
          • McIntyre Tate attorney is successful in obtaining a writ of certiorari in Rhode Island Supreme Court
        • November
          • Superior Court upholds marital settlement agreement trumps pension beneficiary designation
          • Planning for Divorce
          • DEBORAH M. TATE TO SPEAK at "SUPER WOMAN IS A MYTH-- Women, Wealth and Wisdom Series"
        • June
          • Deborah M. Tate And Jerry Mc Intyre Named To Best Lawyers Again
          • RI Supreme Court overturns Family Court ruling on intersection of retirement benefits and alimony.
        • May
          • Rhode Island Supreme Court Overturns Family Court Divorce Ruling
        • January
          • Healthcare agent's financial agreements with nursing home voided
          • McIntyre Tate LLP named a Tier 1 Law Firm
      • 2013
        • December
          • Rhode Island Supreme Court upholds deceased ex-husband's actions under property settlement agreement
        • November
          • RI Supreme Court Upholds Divorce Health Insurance Agreement
          • Robert Parker successful in Rhode Island Supreme Court.
        • July
          • Deborah M. Tate Esq. Named to R.I. Board of Bar Examiners
        • June
          • RI Supreme Court Divorce Decision
          • Rhode Island Supreme Court upholds Family Court divorce decision against absent husband
          • Supreme Court uphold DHS medical assistance claim
          • Rhode Island Supreme Court upholds child custody decision
        • April
          • Nationally alimony laws are being reviewed.
          • Adoption case at U.S. Supreme Court
          • McIntyre Tate LLP attorney David Strachman speaks on executing Durable Powers of Attorney for Healthcare
          • Deborah M. Tate quoted in Providence Journal
          • The rights of unmarried couples in Rhode Island
          • Obtaining Adoption Records
        • March
          • Rhode Island's Voluntary Adoption Registry
          • RI Supreme Court rules in favor of patient killed by nurse overdose.
          • McIntyre Tate LLP attorney David Strachman speaks on terrorism law
        • February
          • Deborah M. Tate Selected to Bar Register of Preeminent Woman Lawyers.
      • 2012
        • August
          • Jerry McIntyre and Deborah Tate Among Best Lawyers in America
    • Contact Us
401.351.7700
McIntyre Tate LLP
Schedule a Consultation
401.351.7700
Home > Blog > 2017 > November > Client Buys Dog in China with Now-Ex-Boyfriend, Ownership Issue Arises
Nov 14, 2017

Client Buys Dog in China with Now-Ex-Boyfriend, Ownership Issue Arises

Posted By McIntyre Tate LLP

Who really owns a dog, a creature with its own free will and decisions to make? How can ownership of anything be established within a couple that never gets married? Does the fact that the dog was bought in a foreign country change anything? All of these questions and more needed to be addressed carefully in a recent dog ownership case in Rhode Island, which highlights just how complex an animal law case can really be.

The Quick Facts of the Chinese Dog Ownership Case

Higgins, the defendant, and the plaintiff, Champagne, in the dog ownership dispute traveled to China together in 2010 so Champagne could complete his studies. Shortly after arriving, the unmarried couple decided to buy a dog together. Both of them assumed near-equal responsibility and cost for the dog, who was named Hector.

In 2012, Higgins had to leave China due to her visa expiring. It was agreed that she take Hector back to the United States when she depart, and, therefore, she was tasked with paying all related expenses to his travel and export. As part of the agreed upon preparation to leave the country, Hector legally and technically became the sole property of Higgins, even though Higgins and Champagne felt they jointly owned Hector.

Higgins lived with her parents and Hector until Champagne could later return to the States, some two years later. Champagne never made an attempt to gain official joint ownership of Hector. Once the couple decided to split in 2015, only then did he try to gain ownership of the dog. Champagne attempted to use documents created in China to show he had ownership rights, but these were found to be unsound evidence to use in an American court of law.

Conclusion: Pets are Not Always “Property”

The court was faced with a difficult decision on how to view the dog. Neither Higgins nor Champagne claimed to be the sole purchaser of Hector. In a normal situation, the dog would be viewed as property and some sort of joint ownership would have to be established.

However, in this specific situation, the court ended up agreeing that the case had to consider what was “best for all concerned,” including Hector. Ruling away from pure property laws, the court held that Higgins belonged with Hector and Hector belonged with her, mainly due to the fact that they spent a great majority of time together; Champagne was more of a secondary owner due to time constraints. Only through this ownership setup could there be established what was “best for all concerned.”

Caring & Trustworthy Rhode Island Animal Law Attorneys

McIntyre Tate LLP has been serving the people of Rhode Island for more than 30 years, and we have more than 150 years of total legal experience. When you come to us for help with your animal law case, you can be confident that we will fight for what is best for you and your furry, feathery, or scaly loved one. Many of our animal law clients are veterinarians and animal adoption clinics who need help with intricate legal and compliance issues. We also focus on animal ownership disputes that can escalate to the courtroom.

Call (401) 351-7700 to request a case evaluation with our Providence animal law attorneys to get started.

Categories

  • Animal Law
Previous Next

Categories

  • Adoption (9)
  • Alimony (6)
  • Animal Law (3)
  • Business (2)
  • Business Insurance (1)
  • Child Support (3)
  • Contract Disputes (1)
  • COVID-19 (3)
  • Custody (12)
  • Divorce (28)
  • Divorce Alimony (1)
  • Domestic Violence (2)
  • DUI (1)
  • Elder Law (4)
  • Firm News (62)
  • Gaurdianship (1)
  • Grandparents Visitation (1)
  • Health Insurance (1)
  • Marriage (3)
  • Our Blog (14)
  • Probate (2)
  • Same Sex Couples (3)
  • Senior Citizen Divorce (1)
  • Spousal support (1)
  • Unmarried Couples (2)
  • Visitation (4)

Recent Posts

  • Attorney Deborah Tate Featured in Bradley Hospital Bulletin
  • Nicholas Hunt Joins Legal Team at McIntyre Tate LLP
  • Attorney Deborah Tate Quoted About COVID-19 Disputes in Divorce
  • How Adoption Works in Rhode Island
  • What Are the Requirements to Adopt a Child in Rhode Island?
  • Is Your Spouse Hiding Money? Create a Fair Divorce Settlement
  • Can a Judge Invalidate a Prenuptial Agreement?
  • Attorney Stephen M. Prignano Recognized by Best Lawyers®

Archives

  • 2022 (2)
    • March (1)
    • February (1)
  • 2021 (17)
    • November (1)
    • October (2)
    • September (3)
    • August (2)
    • July (1)
    • June (1)
    • May (1)
    • April (2)
    • March (2)
    • February (1)
    • January (1)
  • 2020 (14)
    • October (1)
    • September (1)
    • July (1)
    • June (2)
    • May (3)
    • April (3)
    • March (1)
    • January (2)
  • 2019 (13)
    • December (6)
    • November (4)
    • May (2)
    • February (1)
  • 2018 (6)
    • September (2)
    • June (1)
    • February (1)
    • January (2)
  • 2017 (23)
    • December (1)
    • November (4)
    • September (1)
    • August (1)
    • June (3)
    • May (3)
    • April (1)
    • March (2)
    • February (2)
    • January (5)
  • 2016 (22)
    • December (2)
    • November (3)
    • October (6)
    • September (2)
    • August (3)
    • June (1)
    • May (2)
    • April (1)
    • March (1)
    • January (1)
  • 2015 (21)
    • December (3)
    • November (4)
    • September (3)
    • August (2)
    • July (1)
    • June (1)
    • May (2)
    • April (5)
  • 2014 (9)
    • December (1)
    • November (3)
    • June (2)
    • May (1)
    • January (2)
  • 2013 (18)
    • December (1)
    • November (2)
    • July (1)
    • June (4)
    • April (6)
    • March (3)
    • February (1)
  • 2012 (1)
    • August (1)

Contact Us Today

Ready to get started? Fill out the form below, or if you prefer, give us a call at (401) 443-2005. Someone from our office will get back to you.

  • Please enter your name.
  • This isn't a valid email address.
    Please enter your email address.
  • This isn't a valid phone number.
    Please enter your phone number.
  • Please enter your adverse party name.
  • Please select an option.
  • Please enter a message.

Contact Our Rhode Island Attorney

(401) 351-7700

McIntyre Tate LLP

Helpful Links Site Map | Privacy Policy | Law Pay

  • Why Hire Us?
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Family Law
  • Civil Law
  • Forms
  • Contact Us
50 Park Row West,
Suite 109,

Providence, RI 02903 |  View Map [+]
https://www.mcintyretate.com/

Contact Us Today

Ready to get started? Fill out the form below, or if you prefer, give us a call at (401) 351-7700. Someone from our office will get back to you.

  • Please enter your name.
  • This isn't a valid email address.
    Please enter your email address.
  • This isn't a valid phone number.
    Please enter your phone number.
  • Please select an option.
  • Please enter a message.
Site Map | Privacy Policy
Internet Marketing Experts The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.
© All Rights Reserved.
Powered by Scorpion